dipper and non dipper

2 min read 19-03-2025

Dipper vs. Non-Dipper: Understanding the Differences in Pool Design

Choosing the right pool design is crucial for maximizing enjoyment and minimizing maintenance. A key decision often hinges on whether to opt for a dipper or non-dipper pool. This article explores the key differences between these two styles, helping you make an informed choice for your backyard oasis.

What is a Dipper Pool?

A dipper pool, also known as a skimmer pool, uses a skimmer to collect debris and surface water. This water then flows into the pool's filtration system for cleaning. The skimmer is typically located at the waterline, making it efficient at removing leaves, insects, and other floating debris.

Advantages of Dipper Pools:

Efficient Debris Removal: Skimmers excel at removing surface debris. This keeps your pool cleaner and reduces the need for manual cleaning.
Cost-Effective: Generally, dipper pools are less expensive to build than non-dipper pools.
Easier Maintenance: The automated skimming process simplifies pool maintenance.

Disadvantages of Dipper Pools:

Less Water Circulation: Dipper pools may have less overall water circulation compared to non-dipper designs. This can lead to slightly less efficient cleaning in some areas.
Aesthetic Considerations: Some homeowners find skimmers visually unappealing. However, modern skimmers are available in various styles to minimize their visual impact.

What is a Non-Dipper Pool?

Non-dipper pools, also called main drain pools, rely primarily on a main drain located at the bottom of the pool to circulate water. Water is drawn from the bottom, carrying debris with it, and then filtered.

Advantages of Non-Dipper Pools:

Superior Water Circulation: Non-dipper pools typically provide better overall water circulation, leading to more thorough cleaning and a more evenly distributed temperature.
Cleaner Pool Bottom: The main drain effectively removes debris that settles on the pool floor.
Sleek Aesthetics: The absence of a skimmer provides a cleaner, more streamlined aesthetic.

Disadvantages of Non-Dipper Pools:

Higher Cost: Non-dipper pools generally have a higher initial construction cost. This is due to the more complex plumbing required for the main drain system.
Less Surface Debris Removal: While they clean the bottom well, non-dipper pools might not be as effective at removing surface debris as skimmers. Regular manual skimming may be necessary.
Potential for Entrapment: While rare with modern designs, there's a slightly higher risk of entrapment with main drains compared to skimmers. Proper installation and safety features mitigate this risk.

Choosing the Right Pool for You: Dipper or Non-Dipper?

The best choice between a dipper and non-dipper pool depends on your priorities and budget.

Prioritize cost-effectiveness and ease of maintenance? A dipper pool might be the better option.
Want superior water circulation and a cleaner aesthetic? A non-dipper pool is likely preferable.

Consider consulting with a pool professional to discuss your needs and preferences. They can help you determine the best pool type for your specific circumstances. Factors like pool size, shape, and desired features will all influence the decision. Don't hesitate to ask about incorporating both a main drain and a skimmer for optimal performance. This combines the benefits of both systems.

Remember, a well-maintained pool, regardless of whether it's a dipper or non-dipper design, will provide years of enjoyment. The choice between the two comes down to your individual needs and preferences.